OpenRice 主頁      English OpenRice     TableMap     開飯遊踨
   中文 | English
comedicrit
This is comedicrit living in Ma On Shan.I work in Admiralty.
Member 4 First(s)
No. of Review134 Review(s)
編輯推介數目2 Editor's Choice
Recommended9 Recommended
Popularity6745 View(s)
Replies in Forum2 Comment(s)
Upload Photos255 Photo(s)
Upload Videos0 Video(s)
My Recommended Reviews0 Recommended Review(s)
我的餐廳7 My Restaurant(s)
關注0 Following
粉絲4 Follower(s)
comedicrit  Veteran Gourmet
關注 關注  Comment Leave a Message 
Sort By:  Date Smile Smile Cry Cry  Editor's Choice  Overall Score 
Display: AllHong Kong Macau Shenzhen  
 
 
 
 
 
  Full View Full View   |   Map View Map View
Showing 1 to 5 of 134 Reviews
Share with MessengerShare on TwitterShare on Facebook
Categories : Jingchuanhu | Chinese Restaurant

Friday – Dinner for 3 – A La Carte
While the casual setting was fine and unpretentious, the paper place-settings advertising ginger-vinegar-pig trotters created a very Café-de-Coral-like feel. As for the food:-

Shrimp and crab relish on baguette
 
Spoon relish onto one of the 6 thin slices of toasted baguette and voila. This was pretty much all there was to it, which seemed overly simple, like something fixed quickly at home. Perhaps the baguette slices could be slightly buttered, if only for more a more attractive goldenness, or perhaps some salad leaves as well – to reduce the self-made quality.

Crispy stuffed duck with glutinous rice
 
This seemed to be an interesting sandwich-like composition of chewy rice and duck meat. Sadly, neither the glutinous rice nor the duck meat stood out – they both tasted of nothing if not for the sauce. It was really just like eating a clump of glutinous rice…

Crispy tangerine peel spare ribs
 
This was actually the most disappointing – the small bite-sized pieces of pork weren’t crispy and just tasted slightly sweet/sour.

Spring rolls with radish and dried oysters
 
I had never tried spring rolls with this mixture of filling before, and quite enjoyed it –not only were the spring rolls fresh and crispy, the strong taste of dried oyster was delectable too.

Turnip Pancake
 
Again, I felt that this was quite an original recipe, and it was also quite nicely done, such that the edges of the pancake were crispy and there was plentiful plump turnips as well as mushroom and dried shrimp. However, although there was a right amount of batter, it was slightly too mushy and doughy.

Dandan noodles
 
This was an interesting twist to the traditional version, which is worth a try, but in the end I’m still more of a fan of the latter. I find that this lacked peanut sauce and peanut crumbs. The noodles were very al dente, which is a sign of good quality ramen, but personally, I prefer the type of noodles used in the traditional version, which somehow for me, matches the intensity of the sauce more.

DESSERTS
I was most eager to try the desserts, since this is the Sweets branch afterall. Unfortunately, the whole array of durian desserts were not available since it’s not the right season.

Green tea and black sesame glutinous rice balls
 
I’ve heard most about this dessert and decided it had to be good. But… the glutinous rice layer, though not too thick, was completely soft and mushy and totally lacked any chewiness whatsoever. I’m not sure that is deliberate, and if it is, this take on glutinous rice balls is really not my cup of tea.

Cooked pear in osmanthus wine and tofu ice-cream
 
Home-made ice-cream: another must-try item. Sadly, I was rather let down again. It lacked tofu taste and smoothness. It was more akin to sorbet rather than ice-cream. The wine sauce also lacked intensity, and the pears seemed to not have been cooked for long enough.

Caramel glutinous rice and banana ice-cream
 
The pairing of glutinous rice and ice-cream together is incredibly enjoyable, shame about the taste. To me, caramel and banana is itself a mouth-watering combination, but sadly, the tastes of both were hardly detectable. It was really just sweet - if one didn’t know what flavour the ice-cream was, it would have been pretty difficult to tell.

For $220 per head for the above 6 dishes and 3 desserts, it’s not expensive at all. I just didn’t feel it was worth it.

 
Spending per head: Approximately HKD220(Dinner)

Other Ratings:
Taste
 2  |  
Environment
 2  |  
Service
 2  |  
Hygiene
 3  |  
Value for Money
 2

  • Keep it up!

  • Looking Forward

  • Interesting

  • Touched

  • Envy

  • Cool Photo
      View Results
Recommend
0
1400 tasting menu Just OK Nov 05, 2012  
Share with MessengerShare on TwitterShare on Facebook
Categories : Spanish | Western Restaurant | Romantic Dining

It’s been a while since I wrote a restaurant review, but felt that this experience was worth putting into words, firstly because the restaurant is so highly regarded, with its connection to one of the best chefs in the world, and secondly because molecular gastronomy and tasting menus are becoming more mainstream in HK and could use more feedback and encouragement.

We were seated in the VIP area, perhaps due to our reservation of the tasting menu, and were immediately attended to by our waiter, who asked for our order of drinks. Side note - While I understand that fine-dining restaurants do not tend to serve tap water, I couldn’t help but be slightly taken aback with the waiter’s express refusal of the same. I just don’t think a restaurant that cares about food should care that much about charging for water. It’s not like it’s even a ‘drink’ per se, but rather a necessity that should be a right to every customer?

Albeit slightly bummed, I was excited about starting on the first category in the tasting menu - the Snacks. First up: Sangria in suspension and olive oil butter. The sangria part was good, with quite an obvious alcohol content too. Unfortunately, the suspension aspect, which I presume was the crux of the creation, was not as successful. In fact, I was less impressed than I was when I first tried Fruit Tree’s apple & aloe vera juice. Most of the stuff that was meant to be suspended was not, and lay at the bottom of our glasses, resulting in us having to throw our heads back multiple times. I suggest they start serving it with spoons.
 
As for the olive oil butter, I had high hopes for the thick creamy butter that we squeezed out from a cute, miniature toothpaste tube, but was disappointed that the intensity of taste was just as miniature.

Rest of the snacks: Black sesame miso sponge cake and Philopizza ; liquid ham croquette ; truffle dentelle ; foie gras with spiced bread – all were aromatic and composed of diverse flavours and textures as well as delicately presented. However, while they definitely delighted my palate, they did not surprise it in the way that molecular gastronomy usually does. I found myself wondering what other sensations they were intended to conjure or evoke. When the composition of the food plainly just mirrors the food’s name, without further transformation or concept, it’s all but a fine-dining experience, short of a gastronomical journey.

Thus, by the end of the Snacks, I found my mind still in my brain and my socks still firmly on my feet.

Until the tapas: the XXI Century Omelet ; slow-cooked salmon ; and Carbonara Egg Nest. There is a reason why these dishes are the signature ones at this restaurant. I finally felt the extra bit of innovation that reconstructed my food into something more unexpected and out of the ordinary. I particularly enjoyed the Carbonara Egg Nest, which made me feel like I was literally eating a plate of Carbonara which had been reshaped into an egg in a nest. I had no idea how they did it, and loved that. For the record, the slow-cooked salmon was actually just slow-cooked salmon, but it was some seriously good slow-cooked salmon.
 
 
I can’t really say the same for the main courses: French sea bass and wagyu confit. I’m afraid they weren’t only boring, but weren’t even quite up to fine-dining quality. For instance, the texture of the beef was dry and tough and far from tender.

Lastly, the dessert and petit fours. There was (sadly) just one dessert - chocolate coulant nitro. It was good, and I appreciate that liquid-nitrogen-cooked stuff are innovative and rare in themselves, but when it’s the main (and only) dessert item, I felt like it needed something more than just crumbs on the side. As it was, it was nothing special, especially if you’ve already sampled other creations made with liquid-nitrogen. It was like a big, icy Ferrero Rocher, and not as good even, without the hazelnut in the center. As for the petit fours, let’s just say I admired the minimalist way in which they were presented…but not much else. Moreover, to add to the previous outright dismissal of tap water, there was also a minor lack of professionalism in the server’s lack of knowledge about the flavour of the macaroons, and a major lack of professionalism in his failure to revert. I was actually waiting to find out, because even after eating it, I still had no idea (in my defence, it was green, but tasted neither of pandan, green tea nor lime).
 
It’s interesting that, without having taken many photos of the food, I find my clearest memory to be one of visiting the toilet twice and having great difficulty returning to my table both times since its entrance did not revolve along with the rest of the restaurant.

The above sums up my experience of the $1400 tasting menu. I guess on the whole, it still needed some work, whether it be treated as a fine-dining or a molecular gastronomy experience.
 
Spending per head: Approximately HKD1600(Dinner)

Other Ratings:
Taste
 3  |  
Environment
 3  |  
Service
 3  |  
Hygiene
 3  |  
Value for Money
 2

  • Keep it up!

  • Looking Forward

  • Interesting

  • Touched

  • Envy

  • Cool Photo
      View Results
Recommend
0
Not really worth the price Cries Jun 30, 2011  
Share with MessengerShare on TwitterShare on Facebook
Categories : Guangdong | Chinese Restaurant

燒乳鴿
 
Very tasty. But the birds were quite big in size so its chest area was really meaty but lacked tenderness. The prawn crackers were also really crispy.

香酥鴨
 
This dish was well-done, but it was nothing outstanding. It could actually also improve by being crispier…

椒鹽蝦
 
The seasoning was mainly just salt, and I felt it would have been nicer if there was pepper/ chilli as well...

蝦子柚皮
 
Overly salty, and the dried shrimp roe was a bit too weak for me.

送 : 合桃糊
 
This sweet soup was one of the worst of its kind that I’ve ever tasted. It carried no taste of walnut, or any nut, for that matter. It was also composed of many unpleasant clumps of flour, which made it feel like I was eating a bowl of boiled sugar and cornflour.

The chinese dishes aren’t bad here, but not that great either, and I feel they’re overpriced.
 
Spending per head: Approximately HKD250

Other Ratings:
Taste
 3  |  
Environment
 3  |  
Service
 3  |  
Hygiene
 3  |  
Value for Money
 2

  • Keep it up!

  • Looking Forward

  • Interesting

  • Touched

  • Envy

  • Cool Photo
   2 Vote(s)   View Results
Recommend
0
sandwiches Smile Jun 20, 2011  
Share with MessengerShare on TwitterShare on Facebook
Categories : Western | Western Restaurant | Wine | Casual Drink

Grilled vegetables panini
 
Wow. I was pleasantly surprised. At first I thought I’d made a bad choice because veg in bread seems so plain. But it wasn’t plain. In fact, I tasted not only the veg but also a lot of natural salt and pepper AND the chargrilled taste as well, which I did not expect. The veg was varied: mushroom, courgette, sundried tomatoes etc.

Chicken Waldorf salad sandwich
 
The baguette was fresh and crunchy – made me a bit nostalgic for Paul (bakery) in the UK. The filling was great - green apple shreds, water cress, walnut crumbs, chicken meat, celery bits … and there was a LOT of it as well. Perhaps it had a little too much apple and not enough chicken/walnuts, but on the whole, still great.

Smoked salmon :
 
Unfortunately, the baguette this time was not that fresh, and was quite tough to chew… and, the pesto smeared on the inside of it was a bit scant, and the sandwich could have done without it. However, the smoked salmon was of decent quality, and there were a lot of fresh veg, including lettuce, red onions and tomatoes.

Chicken and mushroom panini :
 
This was another good quality panini but its taste was not what I had anticipated. The chicken and mushrooms were not mixed in sauce, but had been fried/grilled, and seasoned – it was perhaps a bit too salty for my liking. However, I loved the big juicy pieces of mushrooms and bits of spinach.

Ham and cheese panini:
 
The ham consisted of generous layers of thin slices. The cheese was not that strong, but was sufficiently cheesy, in a natural way. The panini was very crispy, but it could however have been toasted for a bit longer as the inner layers of ham were still cold.
 
Other Ratings:
Taste
 3  |  
Environment
 3  |  
Service
 3  |  
Hygiene
 3  |  
Value for Money
 3

  • Keep it up!

  • Looking Forward

  • Interesting

  • Touched

  • Envy

  • Cool Photo
      View Results
Recommend
0
not so great dim sum  Cries Jun 07, 2011  
Share with MessengerShare on TwitterShare on Facebook
Categories : Guangdong | Dim Sum Restaurant | Hot Pot | Seafood | Dim Sum

Warning!

芝麻流沙杏仁包
This sounds nice, but it tasted nothing like its name. The bun was grayish in colour, but there was no sesame taste. Similarly, though the filling was white, it had no taste of almond. It was also a bit too watery, and made the bread a bit soggy, as if there was uncooked dough. The bun carried a slight bitter taste as well, which made this quite a bad option as a sweet dessert to end one's meal.

叉燒酥
Cold and unfresh and hardly any char siu in it. Boo.

薄脆金鉤腸粉
I don’t really recall the exact name, but it was roughly like this, which, again, sounds pretty delicious. Unfortunately, again, it wasn’t what was expected: the 金鉤 was merely one or two dried shrimp, and the 薄脆 was deepfried beencurd wrapped inside the cheung fun, which was not 脆 at all. This dimsum was like really plain white cheung fun, that wasn’t even as chewy and smooth as the really good quality ones. Disappointing.

The good thing about eating dim sum at 稻香 is it's relatively cheap. But in my opinion, it's not 'cheap' when the food quality is compensated..
 
Other Ratings:
Taste
 2  |  
Environment
 2  |  
Service
 3  |  
Hygiene
 3  |  
Value for Money
 3

  • Keep it up!

  • Looking Forward

  • Interesting

  • Touched

  • Envy

  • Cool Photo
   1 Vote(s)   View Results
Recommend
0